Search
Sunlit contemporary brick-and-gray townhomes beside a quiet landscaped courtyard in early November.

Goshen Sold Its Millrace Land for Almost Nothing. Here's Why the New Townhomes Still Aren't Cheap

November 12, 2026

TROTM LLC bought the one-acre site along River Race Drive from the City of Goshen for $1. The three floor plans now offered at The Row on the Millrace start at $650,000, $700,000 and $750,000.

These two numbers fit together once you see what the dollar actually bought. Goshen's land deals along the Millrace don't make downtown homes cheaper. They make the homes possible, and the finished product ends up near the same price per square foot as new construction on open farmland at the south edge of town.

The dollar bought a site with problems

The land under The Row is a brownfield. In a story carried by Yahoo News, reporters noted that Goshen began cleaning up the former factory land along the Millrace Canal about 20 years ago. Some industrial buildings in the 14-acre area dated back to the 1860s. The city got $400,000 in U.S. Environmental Protection Agency grants to test the soil and spent more than $2 million in state and federal money removing contaminated soil along the canal.

That cleanup made the site buildable. It didn't make it cheap to build on. The March 2025 Redevelopment Commission packet lists what the city agreed to pay for so the townhomes could go ahead:

  • A Phase I Environmental Site Assessment and help getting a Site Status Letter from the Indiana Brownfields Program
  • Any extra soil sampling, plus excavation and clean-soil capping, to meet IDEM's rule that green space sit under a two-foot cap of clean soil
  • Hauling and disposing of all soil the builder removes during construction, and refilling with clean fill
  • A replat of the subdivision before the land transferred
  • Closing off unused water laterals and taps, and rebuilding any part of River Race Drive torn up by that work
  • Moving the sidewalk next to the curb on South 2nd Street, reshaping the curb line on River Race Drive, and letting the site's stormwater tie into the South 2nd Street system

A lot on clean farmland doesn't come with any of those costs. The city is paying to bring a contaminated, already-platted downtown acre up to the starting line that greenfield land begins at. It isn't paying to push the site past that line, and the house prices show it.

Two earlier plans for this acre never got built

This is the site's third serious attempt. An earlier developer leased the waterfront acre between Monroe and Purl streets about six years before the current deal and planned condominiums. Yahoo News reported that the city took the land back after construction never started. In earlier coverage, The Goshen News linked major delays on the Millrace housing projects to COVID-19 and the jump in construction prices that followed.

Next came Goshen stair maker Viewrail. In June 2023 it proposed a $16 million luxury apartment building of about 50 units, then called Millrace Flats, and applied for Indiana READI 2.0 money that it didn't receive. Viewrail architect Shane Dyer explained the switch to the Redevelopment Commission, as quoted by Yahoo News:

"We made a switch up a year ago just because of the economics of it. The scale needed to make apartments work were probably going to cause a lot of remonstration. With the amenities we needed, it was just too dense, we felt."

So the apartment math needed more units than the acre could reasonably hold. Eighteen owner-occupied townhomes in three buildings of six worked instead. That tells you who the homes are built for. A small number of large units has to cover the same site costs that 50 apartments couldn't, so each unit's price carries a bigger share of them.

Where the price comes from

The project is now marketed by Struxure Develop. Its managing partners, Casey Yerger and Shane Dyer, both worked at Viewrail before. Here is how the current plans compare per square foot, next to the closest new-construction alternative in Goshen, The Tiffany patio home at Cherry Creek, a 170-acre mixed-use community at Waterford Mills Parkway and Regent Street.

Plan Location Listed size Starting price Approx. per sq ft
The Cedar The Row, River Race Drive 2,090 sq ft $650,000 $311
The Beech The Row, River Race Drive 2,270 sq ft $700,000 $308
The Aspen The Row, River Race Drive 2,450 sq ft $750,000 $306
The Tiffany Cherry Creek, south side 1,694 sq ft, with basement $499,900 $295

Two very different sites end up within about $16 a square foot of each other. Cherry Creek has public help of its own. The Goshen News reported an $11 million Indiana Residential Infrastructure Fund loan for its infrastructure. So both projects got public money, and neither price looks discounted. In Goshen, public money for land and infrastructure decides whether new homes get built. Construction costs set what they sell for.

The Tiffany's $499,900 price is marked as expiring Dec. 31, 2026. At The Row, the extra cost buys walking distance to downtown, views of a nature preserve, trail access, and options like Viewrail floating stairs, a stone fireplace and a wood-plank ceiling in the Aspen, which has a private front entrance and a rear two-car garage. "There's nothing like that here in Goshen," Yerger told WNDU, adding that the goal is to attract professionals and help the hospital and local businesses recruit.

The homes also got smaller on paper. The 2025 agreement expected at least 2,500 square feet per townhome and about $15 million in investment. In May 2026 the city approved an amended agreement with final site plans and new milestones, and its October 2026 staff report describes about $9 million in private investment. The current plans run from 2,090 to 2,450 square feet.

The leverage the city holds

The dollar sale wasn't a giveaway. Under the 2025 agreement, the Redevelopment Commission holds a $3 million mortgage on the land to make sure the homes get built, which also lets the city take the land back if they don't. After the condo plan stalled, that clawback is the city's protection.

Goshen is using the same tool one block over. On Sept. 24, 2026, the Board of Public Works approved selling city-owned land in the 200 block of South Third Street, north of West Jefferson, to Struxure Development for Millrace Flats. That's a three-story building of about 38 market-rate apartments with an expected $9.5 million investment, and the city keeps a $1.5 million mortgage until minimum investment levels are met. At that meeting, Assistant City Attorney Don Shuler described the design as still conceptual and still facing zoning steps. Struxure lists the mix as 32 one-bedroom and six two-bedroom units and says it is raising capital now.

For a townhome buyer, the takeaway is practical. The Row's schedule is written into a public contract, so a buyer can read the milestones the developer agreed to with the city alongside the dates in a sales conversation.

The corridor's dates, in order

  1. April 2015. The Hawks at River Art, a former 1870 furniture factory, opens with 19 one- and two-bedroom loft apartments.
  2. Early 2025. AP Development begins work on Ariel Cycleworks at the former Western Rubber site north of Plymouth Avenue, a mixed-use project of about 135 apartments backed by READI grant money. Its leasing site is liveatcycleworks.com.
  3. July 8, 2026. The Row's land transfers to the developer. The October 2026 staff report says earthwork is underway, with Niblock Excavating the apparent low bidder for the public infrastructure.
  4. Spring 2027. Struxure expects The Row's model townhome to open. Pre-sales have already started. WNDU reported March 2027 as the expected completion of phase one, which is six homes.
  5. Spring 2027. Millrace Flats is scheduled to break ground.
  6. July 1, 2027, and June 1, 2029. Millrace Flats' closing deadline and completion deadline under the city agreement.

The schedule shows the buying window. Anyone who wants an owner-occupied new home on the Millrace in the next year is choosing from plans for the first six units, and the model home opens after pre-sales do.

What the county market says about the alternatives

The Row's buyers aren't shopping the median house, though they may be weighing a resale they could buy right away. In Elkhart County, the October 2026 median sale price was $268,000, up 7% from a year earlier. Closed sales fell 10% to 163, and average daily active inventory rose 28% to 483 listings, according to the Indiana Association of REALTORS monthly report. Supply rose to 3.1 months, up 29%, and the median home went under contract in 22 days.

These figures cover the whole county. Higher prices alongside fewer sales and more listings mean a buyer comparing a finished resale with a phased downtown build has more existing homes to look at than a year ago, and a little more time to decide. The Cedar's $650,000 starting price is about 2.4 times the county median, and the Aspen's is about 2.8 times. That gap reflects what the Millrace is selling: new construction within walking distance of downtown, on land the city spent two decades and several million public dollars getting ready.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. If you're considering a pre-sale or a development-agreement property, confirm the details of your situation with an attorney or lender.

If you're comparing a pre-sale on the Millrace with a finished home or a south-side build, Michael Lee can help you line up the specs, per-square-foot math and phase timing side by side before you commit to a plan. Let's Connect.

Follow Us On Instagram